Many film critics today believe that Mani Ratnam and Shankar are becoming outdated. The main reason cited is that they seem to have lost the creative spark—the “fire in the belly”—that once defined their work. This view has gained significant traction on social media, especially after the critical and commercial failures of recent films like Thugs of Life and Game Changer.
Once upon a time, both directors reigned supreme in the industry, widely praised for their cinematic brilliance and innovative storytelling. Now, however, their relevance is being questioned. Opinions vary, but some common criticisms include a lack of originality, outdated screenplays, predictable storylines, and an inability to resonate with modern audiences. Another prevailing argument is that both directors have struggled due to the absence of strong collaborations with talented writers.
Currently, Mani Ratnam and Shankar appear to be in a creative slump, facing the challenge of reconnecting with today’s audience. It may be time for both to reflect and reinvent themselves in order to reclaim their former stature.